Apr. 13, 1977~Aug. 23, 1991
14 yrs. old
Amy Carnevale, 14, was killed by her boyfriend, Jamie Fuller on Aug. 23, 1991. Her body was wrapped in plastic and dumped in the United Shoe Pond on Mckay Street. Her body was found several days later. Amy had a slashed throat, as well as other stab wounds to the heart and upper chest. Cinder blocks had also been placed upon the body to hold it under water.